Full Episode Transcript
Speaker A: I was 10 years in Silicon Valley in biotech before I started Build Memberships, and people are really surprised when we never talk about technology at the start. Is there anything that I can do that is scalable? Are there things that I can create that can help them do better results? Because it will come around.
Speaker B: Ask a membership owner why people cancel and you'll get the usual list: they're too busy, it's too expensive, they just didn't do the work. Nathalie Doremieux has built over 300 memberships, and she thinks this list is mostly a cover story. I'm Vic. This is MemberFix Radio. Today we're getting into what actually drives members out, the reasons that hide in plain sight from someone who spent almost 2 decades in the business. Nathalie, welcome to the show.
Speaker A: Thank you so much for having me, Vic.
Speaker B: So something curious I learned about you, Nathalie, is that running the business with your husband, he fired you twice for acting like an employee. This is what my research showed. Correct me if I'm wrong. Acting like an employee, but not a co-founder. However, today you've helped over 300 entrepreneurs build their memberships. From where you sit now, do you see some of them making the same type of mistake, running their own businesses like an employee rather than a business owner? And when you see it, do you actually point it out?
Speaker A: So Yes. I mean, you're right about the story and I love that you did the homework. Uh, that's something that I used to share a lot in podcasts early on as the story of how I became an entrepreneur and why I do what I do. And I think that first, this idea that you are born an entrepreneur or not, I don't believe it. I think that this is something that you can become. And definitely when we started the business, I was not. And when I said I was acting as an employee, that means that I did not come up with the idea and I just wanted to be told what to do. We came from the corporate and that's kind of the mindset of you have one role and you have some expertise and they, they actually expect you and want you to stay within these boundaries. Being an entrepreneur is very different, especially when you start a business. You have to wear all the hats. And some hats you hate, some hats are uncomfortable, and some hats You don't even know you're supposed to wear them, right? So when we started the business, if you've heard the story, my husband wanted to be, as always, wanted to have his own business. I didn't want to, I wanted security. So not, you know, going and starting something without knowing where it was going. So I, I basically expected him, you know, that, that was not in the conversation, but I expected him to run the business and I would just be like, the nice employee wife that does the work that he wants me to do. And he wasn't seeing it that way. He wasn't seeing it as like, you can bring as much as I can bring. And so it took several years for me to one, figure that out. I had to learn a lot about myself. And, uh, yes, I think it happens to a lot of people. Everyone that is not getting results, every person that I talk to that says, I'm not getting any new members. And I ask, what are you doing to get new members? Well, nothing at the moment. Here we go. Right? So you don't have a strategy. And, and that's because you're not thinking in terms of problem solution. You're thinking in terms of, you know, like, what can I do today? What seems like something that looks doable, but there is no, like, real strategy, real plan.
Speaker B: Mm-hmm.
Speaker A: Right? So I think that it happens to more people that people would care to admit that very often we don't operate as the entrepreneur, but as the employee. Have you created a job for yourself, you know, inside your business? Did you trade a 9 to 5 for 24/7?
Speaker B: Yeah, I love that. It, it, I, it's something I've always said is that it's not so much the case now, but maybe, you know, 10 years ago, 10, 15 years ago when I started doing this. People looked at membership sites almost as a, a business model, but it's really just a delivery vehicle for your value. All of the fundamentals of a business still apply. Just because you have a membership site, it's not gonna automatically make people give you money. You still have to build some audience. You have to have some kind of lead generation. You have to connect with folks. You have to have something valuable to offer. And, and not only that, but valuable on a recurring basis that makes them want to pay you month after month or quarter after quarter, year after year. And just having a landing page and copy and checkout, it's, it's superficial. I mean, you need those things, but that's, that's beside the point, right? It's still a business. It's going to be really hard. It's never going to not be. It's in fact, it's going to probably get harder.
Speaker A: Yeah.
Speaker B: And you need to do all of these things that you probably weren't prepared for and it'll be rough at the beginning.
Speaker A: Exactly. And we don't see this so much now, I think, because people just realize that it just doesn't work. But even like, I don't know how long you've been doing this, but even like 4, 5 years ago, like where we had people who either had a course or they were a coach and they were struggling to sell and they were being told, oh, just do a membership. You know, it's, it's monthly, it's a lower price point, so it's, it's cheaper. So people will join and people thought that, oh, I can just change my delivery system. You know, right now I go. I do coaching or I do a course, let me just put it behind and it's kind of like a, like a payment plan, right? For the program. It just doesn't work that way. So people who wanted to do memberships because it's easier to sell, absolutely not. You know, like you said, the membership is, it's just the delivery model of how you're going to help people. At the core, you're still solving a problem, you know, for people, but you need all those things. I call it MARS. Member acquisition and retention system. You need to bring in people, in the right kind of people. You need to convert them. You need to make sure that they stay. And the one, the only one way that people will stay is if they, is if they get results, if they get what they came for. That thing of like, people come for the content, they stay for the community, that's BS. That might have worked. And I think it was because I was in some of them just for the community. So I can't say it didn't work at some point. That is not the case anymore. Right now, people want results. They are not getting results, they are out.
Speaker B: Yeah, absolutely agree. And I'm seeing that shift too. And as you said, I'm, I'm a part of, still a part of a few memberships and I'm really just there for the community. I don't think I've really consumed any of the content. That content is just table stakes. But there needs to be more. And it's kind of ironic what you said about a coach moving to a membership model, because what I see in terms of retention and results is group coaching is what makes it sticky.
Speaker A: Exactly right.
Speaker B: Or yeah.
Speaker A: So are they a good coach? You know, I mean, are they a good coach? Not in their deliverability, in their marketing. We have to be marketers first, right? Whatever you do, you are marketer first. Everything else is second. Because if you can't market yourself, you can be the best coach or the best teacher. Doesn't matter.
Speaker B: Right. In, in your latest newsletter, you also said specifically that every program has at least one spot where members get stuck and most owners have no idea where theirs is. So short of actually hiring somebody, how can a membership owner— and I use the word membership very loosely, it can mean a kind of—
Speaker A: yeah, me too.
Speaker B: A number of different things, right?
Speaker A: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker B: But how can a membership owner find the weak spots in their program? What's the first step?
Speaker A: So, yeah, so, so what I mentioned in the newsletter, as you said, was related to retention, but also like basically how do you support people? You know, like people stay if they get results. How do you help them get results? And it's easy to say, I share my story, right? Where it affected me for years. You know that story? You know when the coach in the room said to everybody, "I should charge more because you guys are not doing the work." And she was like, "Set." And in my head, I was like, "But hey, I paid a lot of money. I traveled from France to the US 4 times a year to be in that room so that you can help me figure this out. Instead of that, you are telling me," that I should pay more because I'm not doing the work. I'm expecting you to help me figure out why I'm, why am I not? Because I'm not lazy. I pay the money. I do the work, not to the extent that it needs to be done, obviously, but I pay you to help me figure out why, right? So she was not looking at where she can help me. She just had this thing. That has worked for some people who are like, yeah, let me do it, you know. And that's the thing, some people, they get the exact same type of content and support, some people will get results, some people won't. Okay, so if, if you want more results or people to get results, be more successful, right, then you have to figure out why these people are not getting results. So some people will not do the work, they expect that by buying the product they'll get the result without doing anything. But we're not talking about that. We are not talking about the, the people that genuinely want help. They are not given that. The first thing that you need to do, if, if that's your case, if you're like, are there places where I could help some people that are stuck and they are not even telling me, right, is to have metrics and data on how long it takes for people, right? That means you need to start tracking. Most people are not tracking. They say, you know, it's a membership, they don't pay that much. I'm not going to, you know, like do like some one-on-one checking, you know, it's on them to do the work. Sure, you can do it that way, but if you want more results, then now we have tools available where we can really look into what are the places where they could get stuck. So if your program is a framework, you know, and, and they are like certain things that they, they learn and then they have to do something, right? You have to have some type of tracking to make sure that when they've gone through that, have they done the work? And if they haven't, you have to ask them and figure out why, like what's, what's in the way, right?
Speaker B: Yeah.
Speaker A: Very often it's about making decisions. People think that you make a decision and it's set in stone and that's it. Right? So how can you help them make quicker decision, right? And faster, you know, shorter decision, you know, like smaller decisions faster. That does a lot of things that builds their confidence in that trade-off. That gives them some type of clarity. Oh yes or no, but at least you move forward, right? So it's, it, it comes down to that. It's like you have to know your, your members and figure out like, are there key spots where people, you know, get stuck? Like if you do calls, for example, and you see the same questions coming up week after week after week, you know, still working on that, still working on that. Okay. And then you think in terms of problem solution. Okay. That's the problem they seem to be having. Is there a tool, a resource I can create? To help them.
Speaker B: Yeah, 100%. It, it, it's part of that conversation we, we had in the LinkedIn comments, which is an attitude. And this is also coming back to the art of entrepreneurship, if you will, which is that you are responsible for everything. This coach who said to the, the students in your experience that, uh, hey, you guys aren't doing the work, I should charge more. That's a terrible thing to say because first of all, you're shifting blame from yourself. I mean, you created the program, you qualified these prospective participants. Like, it's all on you. And even if it's not all on you, if objectively somebody is being extremely difficult, you know, that kind of thing does happen, it still might not be your fault, but it's still your opportunity to take ownership and think, you know what, if I could find a way to make this more digestible, if I could remove friction for my members, how— and just being relentless in really trying to help people, they'll probably get a better result. And you always have to turn it back on yourself and like, how can, how can I make this better, easier, more seamless?
Speaker A: Yeah, exactly.
Speaker B: And it's a hard pill to swallow.
Speaker A: Yeah, it is. And I think some people are doing it. Some people are completely ignoring it. And when you run a business, you have to look at, I mean, we pay so much attention into our marketing, our sales, and how can I convert better and what can I tweak for the sales page? But somehow when it comes to the delivery, all people seem to care about is, am I getting testimonials? Am I getting case studies?
Speaker B: Mm-hmm.
Speaker A: So when you get these people that share, you know, like that's one of my pet peeves, you know, we don't see that much anymore, maybe because they're not getting those results. But you know, those people that sell courses or even like big memberships and they make 7-figure, multiple 7-figure. And they always have 40 or 50 case studies, you know, videos of people saying, hey, I got results, I'm super happy, great. But like, for these 50, you've got thousands that are still stuck. And they are the people I'm thinking about. Because when you can sell, you can sell a lot. But do you even know about all these people that maybe you could help? So that's kind of like my message today would be like, in my dairy, I know it's not directly connected to making more money, but it is because you're looking at the lifetime value of your member, right? And your church.
Speaker B: That's right.
Speaker A: Can I, is there anything that I can do that is scalable? So it's not about me showing up on more calls, you know, adding, you know, more members, you know, into my team for support and stuff, but Are there things that I can create that can help them do better results? Because it will come around. They will talk about the program. They will, you'll get more testimonial, you'll get more of this, right? So it will come back to you eventually, but it's about how can I create a better delivery systems? And with the tools that we have right now, they have no excuse.
Speaker B: For sure. You've even compared What's the best membership platform to asking what's the best car? Speaking of, of the same type of topic, your point being, I think that people reach for tech before they've really thought about more fundamental things like the offer, the transformation that they're offering, their zone of genius, where, what they can really offer. So when an established owner who did do their thinking comes to you and they're convinced that the platform is the bottleneck, which may or may not be right. How do you tell the difference between a platform they've genuinely outgrown versus a design or user experience issue in the program? You know, or maybe they're not surveying their members, or maybe they're being lazy in some way. What, what questions do you ask?
Speaker A: I think that like, basically what I tell people is that it's rarely the tech. I am a tech person. I am a software engineer. You know, I was 10 years in the Silicon Valley in the biotech. Before I started Build Memberships. And people are really surprised where, when we never talk about technology at the start, because the tech is just the tool to make the thing happen. So when people start saying, you know, like, this is not working, and they're looking about details in the program that to me are not what they need to focus on. So we take a step back and we're like, what is going on? Because if you're talking about the platform, that means that there is an issue with people. Is it consuming? Is it that people are complaining about certain things, right? So it's, it's taking a step back. It's like, what are you trying to do? So these are my non-negotiables and these are the nice to haves. Okay. And then what experience do you wanna create? What kind of onboarding do you want? Do you want something that is interactive? Like the first time they come in, there is something. And then once they've completed the onboarding, the next time they log in, that thing goes away. You know, that's kind of like how we create memberships because people like to see that thing changes. They like to see that they are making progress, right? So, oh, I've done this. This is where I'm at. They like to be able to go back to where they were. They also need to see what they've completed, right? Like whether this is percentage or checks or things like that, right? So you have to figure out how is your audience, how can you best support your audience with that? And, and then we can look at the tool, but the tool is rarely the problem. It could be how it is being used. Now, some people are set in stone in using certain tools. So you do WordPress like me, you build membership sites as well. But when I have somebody that comes from Kajabi, for example, We've moved people away from Kajabi to WordPress. Not saying Kajabi is bad. It's not bad at all. It's just a box and you have to fit within the box. So if you create your membership within what Kajabi does really, really well, you can be successful. There are tons of people successful, but if you start to complain that, oh, you can't do this, you can't do that, that means you've outgrown that platform. And then we can talk about not what's the next tech, but like What it is that you are missing that you wish you could do, and then we'll figure out the tools to make it happen. So that's my approach. The tool, the tool is rarely the problem. It's more like what is the, the structure and the experience that you're trying to create and what problem are you trying to solve? If you come to me because you think the platform is the problem, let's figure out what is the underlying problem.
Speaker B: For sure. I always say form follows function. Right? What are you trying to do? And then figure out, and, and I'm always, my attitude is always I'm agnostic to the particular tool. It doesn't even have to be WordPress, right? It could be Kajabi, it could be something completely custom.
Speaker A: Mm-hmm.
Speaker B: And it doesn't even have to be a particular membership plugin, but it's like, okay, what are you trying to do? Okay. And not only now, but into the future, because you have to think about your next steps, you know, because what got you here isn't gonna get you there. And if you manage to scale to, you know, 100 members, 1,000 members, You're gonna have different needs and requirements. So let's maybe think about that a little bit now. And, but as you say, Natalie, that it's, it's a secondary conversation. It's not the root. And I understand the perspective of, of folks because they, the marketing is so good that they're like, MemberPress is gonna like save, save everything, or Memberium is gonna save everything. It's like they all do more or less the same stuff. They're not gonna save you from the work, the hard, the hard boring work that you need to do. That's what you need to do, right?
Speaker A: Yeah, exactly. Remember that there are memberships that we've built. I mean, I think about this guy like John Burgos is Living in the Extraordinary. He's got hundreds and hundreds of members. He does one call a week and we put the replay. That's it. There is no community, there is nothing, and he's thriving. So it's about finding what people need and just give them that, nothing more. You know, if we talk about content, you know, and what you should put in a membership, it's the same thing. It's like, it doesn't need to put more. Actually, putting more could put people off and feel overwhelmed, like, I'm getting too much, I'm not consuming half of what he's giving, I'm out, right? So it's, it's, people would think like, this is complexity, you know, there needs to be a lot of things and things like that. And I get that when you have a more junior Audience, they want more stuff.
Speaker B: Mm-hmm. They think they do.
Speaker A: They, they think they do. Yeah. I mean, they want more stuff. They think they need, but they definitely want, oh yes, I want this bonus. I want that thing. I want that, right? They'll never do anything with it probably, right? But it feels like, ooh, this is more stuff I need. And it's really not about that. You and I both, both know that, right? That the tech is really not such a big deal, right? It's about, okay, it needs to do that, that, that's Sounds like a gold tool stack to use.
Speaker B: So I'm wondering, Natalie, an owner of a membership or a platform, sometimes they don't notice the slow fade, right, of, of the membership. They just see the cancellation notification in the inbox, and then the member probably mentally checked out weeks earlier, right? So the cancellation is, is the final decision that might have been brewing for a while. So Put me in that member's shoes the month before they click cancel. What might be going on with them? What are some of the reasons that cause people to churn?
Speaker A: So the first obvious reason is they've, they've seen the payment go through months, 1 month, 2 months, 3 months. They still haven't logged in. So they're like, okay, I'll join again if I need it, but I'm just going to cancel. This is money I'm paying. I'm not doing anything with it. Right. Then what I've seen and I've been part of is like you sign up because this is something that you need, but the delivery format is not working for you.
Speaker B: Hmm.
Speaker A: So for example, the only way you can ask questions is if you go on a call and there are 1,000 people on that call. And even though I can make videos, I can do these interviews, I can talk to people, no problem on a call. Raising my hand to ask a question is hard for me. It's, there is a tension for that because I'm like, why would he pick me? There are so many people and you have all these extroverts that are like, me, me, me. And they always are always there and they always get picked. So it's not for me. So that delivery system doesn't work for me. So I might like the person and my, I might believe that their solution, their way of doing things could work for me. But the delivery format isn't working, right? So people would leave for that. And it's, it's not like they're unhappy or like they're not mad or things like that. It's just like, if one day you do like a small core thing, I might come back, but like this delivery doesn't work for me. And then you have the people that are there, they like consume, consume, consume, you know, they take a bunch of notes, they have all the notebooks and stuff like that. But then they're always, you know, they're in the community, very active, and that they're posting and asking questions, but behind the scenes, they never send an email. Yeah. Right.
Speaker B: They mistake activity with, with progress.
Speaker A: They feel, yeah, they feel busy, like active, like you said, but they are not really taking the step that will actually, you know, make a difference and give them, and it's a whole bunch of fears. What will people say? You know? It's not good enough. It's like, what if they say no, right? So it's a no by default. If you don't send the email, by the way, it's a no by default. It's zero conversion. Okay. So there's that. So there's, you know, so many reasons. And then there are people that thought that it was something and it was something else, you know, like, oh, but you're not talking about how to, you know, like something super specific. I'm out, right? So like so many different ways, reasons why people, people, and sometimes there is life, like something happens and you have, you know, a health situation or something and you have to, they ask usually sometimes they ask to pause if you can pause or they'll cancel, right? So I mean, they're like very different reasons. That's why we have to design a cancellation process where people feel seen. And that's like really, really important.
Speaker B: For sure. And ideally, you know, not pressured or there's no friction and you, you actually can create a space where they, where you can ask 'em like, hey, I, I'd really love to know why you're leaving. You know, no judgment. We, we just wanna do a really good job for you if you ever come back. And then for any other members, because we have blind spots, we're humans, we don't know everything. Like running a business is hard. All, all of it, you know?
Speaker A: Yeah, exactly. Yeah.
Speaker B: Yeah. Oh, okay. Before we blame psychology, which, which is definitely a huge part, how much of what shows up as a cancellation isn't a decision per se on, on the side of the member, but maybe it's something like an expired card, a failed charge, not getting emails, a bad user experience. And, you know, across 300+ builds, how much of these issues can be traced to tech? Is there some percentage that Yeah, that's actually like a tech thing.
Speaker A: I don't have an exact number, but like, I think if you design your failed payments— I mean, all these need to be automated, obviously, otherwise nothing is scalable, right? But if you design it so that you have people have reminders so that they can go back and fix their credit card and things like that, then you're greatly going to lower that. And the— and there are people that know that the card is expired and would just let it die, you know, like they will not do anything because they don't, they want to cancel. They're like, oh, it's going to cancel on its own, the card is old. That happens, you know, a little, you know, like if you reach out to people, you find that out. But generally speaking, I think that that number, we can't do anything about it. All you can do is make sure that you have the right automations to manage those expired cards, you know, and changing payment plans or changing all these things. What really matters is that you catch people that actually want to cancel. So one, you make them able to cancel right away. Don't ask them to send an email. That's the worst thing you can do. It's happened to me, and it's a small amount, but immediately it feels like They're gonna make me jump through hoops and I don't want that right now. You also don't do, do you want a free month? Do you want na na na? You know, like before you can actually cancel, you know, some big memberships, they do that. That's not a good idea. It just, if I want to cancel, yes, you want information, I'll give it to you if you make it easy for me. So ideally for me, like the cancellation is Okay, we got your request. So they get to a page, you got your request to cancel, no problem, you're gonna be able to cancel on this page. Now before you go, I'd love to know, is there anything we can do to support you? Like, this is where our next call is happening, and optionally, like, if you want to hop on a call with someone, if you have a specific question, here is a link. Yeah, either way Here is the button to cancel. And like, like you said, you know, have an open-ended box that is optional. People should not have to tell you. A no is a no. Is there anything where, was there any point where you got stuck and wish there was something that could happen? And, and that's it. And you allow them to cancel right there.
Speaker B: Totally agree. I think it's just basic respect for people's autonomy and their giving you their money that they worked really hard for. And if you put any roadblock in front of them canceling, like, that immediately is going to be like, what the hell? And that's what you think.
Speaker A: You think like, yeah, this is the last thing they will remember about you.
Speaker B: Great point. That's right.
Speaker A: That's the last thing they remember, how you made them feel. Remember how you make people feel on the signup, on the onboarding, inside. Feel seen. How do you make people feel seen when you have thousands of people inside. There are memberships where you leave and you don't get a single email about, we're sorry to see you go. Yes, I know it's an automation, but at least I feel a bit seen, right? So I think that we can create these experiences at scale. And, and very often people think, oh, because it's— I have thousands and thousands, if there are 10 that leave, doesn't matter. That means you treat people as numbers and not people. And I don't think that's the right way.
Speaker B: Hmm.
Speaker A: Yeah.
Speaker B: And coming, coming back to this idea that a lot of people who sign up, they don't necessarily want results. They just want like the dopamine rat pellet of more and new and shiny. And my observation has been from working with a lot of memberships that Oftentimes people sign up for a program or membership, and not only do they not consume the content or do the steps to get the result, they don't even log in. Like, they'll just be paying for months or a year, maybe convincing themselves that, okay, like, next month I'm doing it. Oh, like, next month, January, New Year's resolution. I don't know what people say to themselves. I've done it. I don't, you know, I'm not above the mental— what would you call it? The cognitive biases. Where you can convince yourself of something. And I've seen you make a similar comment, right, that passive members— so these are people who consume a lot, take a lot of notes. You got the notebooks, right? But implement very little in terms of actually moving the needle. But they're not really at fault, right? And to be fair, sometimes a member just isn't putting in the work. But in your opinion, could— how do you design a program to filter for people who are actually ready and willing and like, how do you make sure you have the right people in, if you can even?
Speaker A: Yeah. So there was one filter and that might be controversial, but it's, I think it's true. It's the price. It's the price.
Speaker B: I love it. Yeah.
Speaker A: Because will you pay $500 a month for a membership and do nothing, but just have it just in case? Or would you pay $47? And have it just in case. I've done it plenty. Okay. So it's the price you are okay to lose every single month because you have that safety net of saying, I have it if I want it. Right. So when you price so that it becomes an investment, not an amount of money that sometimes people even forget they have $27 a month, you know, especially if they have a lot of subscriptions, it's quickly drowning in the middle of other stuff, right? So this, I'm not saying you shouldn't charge these amounts. I'm just saying you're gonna get different type of people. Same thing, like if you are working with a big transformation, you are not gonna join a $27 or $47 a month membership. So It's tied to the level of transformation that you're going to provide, and it's going to attract different people. Now, the, the way to attract the right members, how do you make sure they're the right members? You gotta be really clear. Of course, you know, we are not gonna talk about the avatar, all that stuff. You know, we know that, like, what's your ideal member, right? But when you first launch your membership, what I tell people to do is to actually co-create with people. And when somebody comes to me, I used to say yes to these memberships. Now I don't anymore. But when people, someone comes to me and say, I wanna create a membership, you know, I have this expertise, you know, I wanna create a membership. And I like, and, and she's like, yo, can you build a platform like this person? Because we have our links in the footer. So they're like, I was in this membership, I like it, I want the same thing. And I used to build it. And now I'm like, have you validated your offer? Do you have an interest list? And people are like, no, I don't have it yet, but you know, I know my stuff. I know people want it. So I've built too many of these that never got launched. Okay. So I don't want to do that anymore. So I tell people the best way to figure out who are your ideal members is to build it with them. So you build an interest list. That means you ask people to raise their hand for free and say, I'm thinking about doing this. It's for this type of people, and this is the problem that it's going to solve. Are you interested? You don't tell them the price, what it is, when it comes, nothing. Just that. And I tell people, if you're not able to do this, to get people to raise their hand for free, how do you expect people to pay later? And usually there is a big silence. They're like, she's asking me to do the work already. Yes, this is the hard work. This is you showing up. This is you showing that you're excited about your ideas. How many people I have talked to that were not excited? I couldn't see like the sparkle in their eyes. I'm like, you, you don't feel excited. I'm not excited about how can I help you as a coach, you know, if you are not excited, right? So let's figure out why. And sometimes it's because it's not membership, it's something else. It happened several times. So that's the first thing, you know, you have to get the right people in that interest list. And then you go into co-creation with them. You figure out what it is that they want, and you have also what it is that you want, how you want to show up. Never say, oh, I'm gonna be there like every single day at the start because they need me. That's, that's the recipe for burnout, right? How do you wanna show up in there? Cuz it needs to be working for you and scalable. And what do they want? And the, at the intersection of that, is your membership. It's going to work for them and it's going to work for you. And when I ran that, I, I had a program, it's called— it's closed now, but it was called First Members, and it was a group program where I was getting people to that. I had people convert 40— I think the biggest one was 60% of their interest list into paying members. Wow, huge number, right? But why? Because they were already sold. By the time you, well, they were like, let me in, let me in. And by the time you open the door, they already feel like they belong. They helped create it, right? If you do a, I don't know if you do a little bit of a psychology, you know, persuasion, but it's like the ownership model, right? It's like if they feel like it's already a little bit of their own. One, you don't have to do the guesswork because they're telling you, but that also dictates what are the future members that you want. Which is your questions. Because there is nothing worse than opening the door and trying to get everybody possible inside. Because when you're going to get feedback, you don't want to get feedback from people that are not your ideal members. And I'm sure you know what I'm talking about. You know, these people that are always complaining that this and that and this and that. Like, you don't want these people getting feedback from the wrong members. Is the best way to feel confused and to make you want to give up. And I've seen that.
Speaker B: Natalie, you make me think of something I've heard Alex Hormozi say, which is that, you know, people are protesting. He puts out so much content and he says you should do 100 times more content too, which, okay, philosophically could be quality versus quantity type of argument. But let's say you agree with his thesis, then people say, well, most of this content, it'll get seen and then it'll just disappear into the interwebs forever. Why should I do it? I like— the asset is gone. And what he said is that, well, you're not trying to make content so that you could stack content. You're building an audience. You're built— you're creating goodwill. You're giving value to people so that when you finally ask for something, you've accumulated so much goodwill that they will be with, take, take my money. Right? Because they already know, like, and trust you. You've already given them tons of value for free, you know, and Hormozy is really a great example. I got so much of him for free that as soon as he launched anything paid, I'm, I'm buying it. And I'm sure there's examples of other people who, you know, who you follow that are, have a similar thing happening.
Speaker A: Yeah. I follow him, you know, as well. And it's that thing, you know, like with generating content, basically you're, you're building your audience, right? Generating. So, you know, there was one thing we need to say. It's like, we can't do what Alex Hormozy does. Let's be really, really clear. Because he's special. Well, he's special, but even those people, we, we have to— it's not about even comparing, but it's like we can't do the same thing. Remember, every time he posts something or he sells something, people are going to buy just because of the name. He has an established brand. He has some loyal super fans that, you know, will trigger the algorithm so that by default he gets gets, you know, thousands of views and things like that. So we are not in that space, right? So we have to be very, very careful if you're trying to copy what these people are doing. So copy what he's saying, sure, but what he's doing, the way he's doing it, it just doesn't work, right? I think it kind of makes sense, right? We don't have the same audience, we don't have the same reach. But in terms of creating, sharing content, Absolutely. I think that one mistake that I've made for years was to be— I don't know how far you went when you chat, but like, I used to like to be like really to the point and just education, education, education, education. And talking about me, my values, what I stand for, like what I hate, like was really, really hard because I felt like like people don't care about that, but we have to realize that people, whether they care or not, is not even the questions. It's like they need to hear this. At the end of the day, people do business with people. So if you spend, you know, like if you share your cat or your dogs, you know, like every day, that's, that's maybe you're going to get the likes, that's engagement, but it does nothing to you. But it's like you have to find that right mix. Of, you know, educating and entertaining and showing you like if you're, if you're funny or like things that you like, but also what you stand for, you know, like I, I don't like to post things that like piss me off or things like that. And every time I do that, I have my husband who says, hey, you're angry at that of that again, you know, why do you, why do you do this? And same thing when I share the story, you know, with the coach, he's like, huh. You're still stuck on that. And I said it in the message because he told me, and I knew when I posted the newsletter that he would come to my office smiling. And I'm like, I know why you're here, and I'm posting it anyway because it's me, because it's sticking. It's when you think about it, it's part of why the member experience is so important to me, because she let me down. And she let down a lot of other people. I don't know if I shared this in the newsletter, but at the end I went to her. So it's like hundreds of people, you know, like 400 or 500 people. At the end of the retreat, I went to her and I spoke to her, and she said this one sentence that is even worse than what she said. She told me, I hope you make it.
Speaker B: Hmm.
Speaker A: A coach, leadership coach telling you that. I hope you make it.
Speaker B: Thanks for the money. Good luck.
Speaker A: Yeah. 16K per year or whatever that was. No, thank you. And I was like, I'm out. I'm out. She doesn't believe in me. She makes me feel less than, and I'm out. So those are things that even they're uncomfortable to me, I want to share because I know people. I mean, there were people in this room sitting next to me. That was thinking the same. It's like, what the— and all these ladies, I still know them. The program doesn't even exist anymore. She went on to create something else. So those things are things are important. The, you know, the journey, like what we're going through, like not just the great stuff, you know, and you have to find that balance. You know, some people want to be more, don't want to share the personal stuff, but to some extent people need to understand You know, like I have 3 kids. Well, they, they are 29, 27, and 21. So they are not that age, right? But I, I never share about them just because that's something that I don't want to share, right? That's all, right? And I, and people go in that and they share their kids and their stuff and stuff. And, and that's great. So you have to find what works for you, like, but at the end of the day, people need to be able to see on social, which is not really social anymore, right? Who you are. Yeah. Maybe more than what—
Speaker B: Yeah, especially if your personal brand is in any way tied to sort of the sales process or the delivery that, you know, you need to have a personality, you need to have some charisma. As you said, people need to understand your values because that actually helps the whole qualification process, I forget who said it, it might have been Frank Kern or somebody, but basically it was like, you need to polarize people. That's the job of your copy is to actively reject the people who, you know, it's kind of like, this isn't for you. This isn't for you. Here's all the reasons why this isn't for you. And like to the person who, who it's not for, they're gonna be like, well, fine. Like, I, you know.
Speaker A: Yeah. You know, so, And it's hard, and it's hard because you don't want that. You feel like it's like a negative comment, but like, if you don't piss off people, that means that you don't have a point of view that is strong enough. And right now we know that when people are signing up to something, right, it's, it's because you are making a shift in how they think. So if you can go against the grain, against what everybody else is saying, like, you know, it's not so much anymore, but people used to say, you know, add content to your membership every month, you know, like, what can I add, what can I add, and do this and do that. Oh, and I have a tutorial for all possible plugins, you know, and stuff like that, all the CRMs. And people are never going to use that. It becomes this huge library, and you think you're giving value where you're giving overwhelm, right? Um, And so I think that that's really the key. It's like showing, you know, what you stand for. And as I get older, it gets so much easier because now I can tell you, I don't give a damn about what people think. So it's a lot easier.
Speaker B: You make me think, Nathalie, of— I worked with James Schramko, who's this really excellent business coach, wonderful guy. And I joined his entry-level membership, which was something like $20. Well, he's always experimenting. So. It's, it's different already. But at, at the time I joined, which is about 2 years ago, it was, I think, $20 and you got access to a forum with some other members of that level. And he did a, a group, like a large group, uh, coaching thing. And then I upgraded to his private group coaching, which is a small group coaching. And you lose access to the forum, you lose access to all these other people. And all you have is a private, no recording group coaching call, I think 3 or 4 times a week with I think not more than 6 or 7 people. And I was like, hmm, this is interesting, James. Not only did I not get more stuff, I got less stuff. He's like, yeah, because the people at this level don't want to be in a forum, you know, bullshitting with like a bunch of others. No, they want like results. They're serious. They're paying serious money. They want to connect with other high-level entrepreneurs and they want me to help them solve their problems and their commitment reflects the level of transformation. The financial commitment reflects the level of transformation that they're seeking. I was like, that makes a lot of sense. That's very logical.
Speaker A: Yeah, exactly. And that, that's the kind of thing that is going to polarize, right? People are like, it's not recording. It's only calls. I'm not in. Good. That's not for you. Right. So that's one way, you know, like, and that's because he knows this, the ideal audience for this really, really well. And he knows that it's not going to serve them. That's why, like, there are so many different ways to, to run a membership. At the end of the day, like I said, it's a problem, a solution. And if you can give it to people with less content, less calls, even better, because people are busy. You want people to be in the doing and give them the proper support and accountability that they need, but you don't want them to be in the consuming.
Speaker B: Absolutely. If anything, there's a problem with, with overconsumption. There's so much information. And one of the interesting conclusions that I heard you share was that if everyone, meaning membership site owners, have the same content and outcomes are different, can be different between these, you know, two, two different sites, let's say, uh, then probably content was never the thing deciding who succeeds and who leaves. But the difference is support and accountability, which is your model that you came up with. Which is content support accountability. Also very logical, but there's perhaps a trap on both ends, right? An owner can bury a member in content, as you said, or bury themselves in an unscalable situation where they have endless personalized support, weekly calls, unlimited access, and it becomes this 24/7 nightmare. So where's the line? Like, should the owner set some ground rules and should you do things that are not scalable? At the beginning and then how do you leave that? Like, how do you get out of that and continue to grow if you even want to grow? Because some people, there's an assumption that you should always scale, but some people don't actually want that.
Speaker A: Yeah, exactly. Great question. I'm working on something and it won't be scalable because I want to cap it to a certain number of members. So that's perfect. So this is what I think and I think it's controversial. I don't talk about it enough, but I think that when you first launch your membership, it's not about the money. And you should probably limit the number of people that can get in. Why? And, and you can make things that are unscalable. Why? Because you are figuring out what your solution is going to be. You know the problem you're solving and you think you know like the different elements of the solution. But you need to figure out in live with people what the solution, what's the format of the solution. So when you first launch, let's call it a beta, you know, something, you know, your first launch, when people, they, when they join, they know that it's for a period of time and the format might change. It's that period where we are figuring things out. Right. And in that time, allow yourself to spend the time to talk to members individually, to figure out where do they get stuck. You know, like if you're not sure how many calls you should do, you know, people are like, oh, I'm gonna promise 3 calls a week because they're all excited. And then 6 months in, they can't take it anymore. And it's always the thing, people coming to the 3 calls and you're like, damn, they're getting 3 calls and it was supposed to be for other people. All things, you know, come up when you do this. So again, it's about limit the number of people. So it's actually a tight group that you are comfortable with. So for some people it's, it's very tiny. It's for some people it's 10, 20, for some people it's 50 or 100, whatever makes you feel comfortable and feel, feel like you can connect with these people and gather the information you need and tweak things. They know when they join that things are going to evolve. Right? Some people may, some things might get removed, some things might get added, but this is the place where you figure it out. You figure it out. So you get paid because people have signed up, but you also get the feedback from these people. Once you've figured that out, your next launch, then this one is about, but you know exactly it's about making money. It's, you know exactly who your members are. You up your price, right? Usually, because that should not be your price. Price that these people got in. And you have a process that people have gone through that you're comfortable running, that sounds scalable to you, and that gets people results. And to me, that's the key, and that's what I've seen work.
Speaker B: Yeah, makes total sense. It's also quite a scientific process because you're essentially— you have a hypothesis, right, of how you're going to deliver it. You don't actually know because you haven't gotten real feedback from the market, from from real human beings. But then as you start to deliver, you, you figure out where you were mistaken and you get probably ideas from your members and you can improve and iterate. And then the next iteration is better and it should cost more because essentially these people were getting a discount for co-creating with you, uh, what, what the program delivery looks like. It makes total sense.
Speaker A: Yeah.
Speaker B: And your CSA model, like on the same topic, it says that Support has to catch people the moment they get stuck, which I thought was really, really fascinating, right? So you get stuck now and, and you're immediately getting some kind of intervention, not, you know, 3 days later or the next group call. So mechanically inside the site, what does that look like? Is it like an AI chatbot assistant that's part of the lesson? Is it a progress trigger that, you know, fires an email, you know, because you're tracking, let's say, lesson progress? Are humans being involved? Like, how do you intervene at that sensitive point where somebody is getting annoyed and probably starting to think like, ah, screw this, I'm gonna cancel?
Speaker A: Yeah. So, so basically, and you're right, it's, uh, some of the things that we do are AI tools that we create, but they're not just like, I mean, you can have like 25, 30 AI tools, right? It's not like one assistant that knows everything and can do everything. We know that doesn't work that well, but It, the idea is like when, when you are teaching something in a video and you ask them to do something, right? You can create a tool to help them make that decision. That can be help them draft an email, that can be help them do a role play on a conversation that they need to have over the phone with someone, right?
Speaker B: Mm-hmm.
Speaker A: So it's, it's basically a tool to help them take action that is going to guide them. It's almost like having a coach next to you and ask you some questions and say, okay, so let's brainstorm, give me some stuff, you know, because a lot of the reasons why people are not moving is because they're not quite sure, you know, either it's the blank thing, like they don't know where to start. So that gives them a start. Or it's like, they don't know if it's good enough. Right. So they need that confidence. And when you're in a membership, you're not gonna have that one-on-one for every single micro decision that you need to make. So if you build into the learning, whether this is a course, by the way, or a membership, right? We, the term is loose for membership. It's about not being a consumer, but being a, I don't know if you saw that, I, I call it the learn-do loop.
Speaker B: Mm-hmm.
Speaker A: You're learning, doing, learning, doing. So, Every training, everything that you teach them needs to be attached with some type of action they need to do. Because then what the membership is, it's like, it's a companion, it's an implementation program, right? And if, if you do it that way where you have a tool attached to the thing that you're asking them to do, the, the easiest way to look at it is like, you know, when they give you that That makes me smile because I've never filled any single one of them, but I've downloaded a bunch. This PDF worksheet workbook fillable. I feel like I'm at school. Oh yes, he said that word. Let me put it there. You know, that does nothing to my business. That doesn't do anything to my business. And I get what they're doing it because it puts people in and for some people it's enough. We can do so much more now.
Speaker B: Hmm.
Speaker A: With AI. So, so that's, to me, that's what people expect now. It's that level because AI is everywhere and I know it's crap in a lot of places. I mean, I got into fights with bots so many times just because they keep saying the same thing and they're like not listening to me and trying to sell me something when I ask a specific question as a client. You should upgrade, you should— here we are talking about a very specific, you know, one role. It's the equivalent of having a human and saying, what does the human need to know in order to help you do this exercise? Just this one. Doesn't have to know the whole program, like just this one thing, right? And to me, that's where AI can shine at helping people get results. Results faster by helping them implement.
Speaker B: From what you just said, Natalie, the thing that stuck out to me was the idea of using AI for role play, which I think is, is, is brilliant because, uh, we have, so there's a client that we work with and they teach leadership, leadership training. And one of the big tools that they have, I mean, it's really applies to anything where you're coaching somebody is role playing. So for example, they'll do a role play where on how to take ownership, right? Favorite topic of ours. And so like, I'll be the boss and you're like the employee that, you know, messed something up. And then you come to me and I'm not taking extreme ownership and I'm blaming you. And whatever you say, I'm like, why did that go wrong? What happened, Natalie? Why didn't you do your job? And then you flip it. And so you can feel what it feels like when somebody is taking extreme ownership on the boss side what it feels like when they're not, what it feels like when the employee is taking extreme ownership and what it feels like when they're not. And so it's a really powerful tool, but you can absolutely, now AI is at the level where you can do that with like AI voice and, and train it really like quite well. Is it the same as a human? No, but it's, there's an 80/20 there and in a year or in a couple years, is it gonna be like a human? Yeah. So you may as well get in front of it.
Speaker A: Exactly. And you know that like there are some coaching programs where they would do, uh, breakout rooms and role play.
Speaker B: Mm-hmm.
Speaker A: And let's be honest, it is uncomfortable for some people. Some people are like, yes, let's do it. And some people are like, oh my gosh, I don't like role play. Here you are in front of a bot. Who cares? Right? It's about practice. And practice with no judgment is what builds the confidence. And a lot of the reason why people are not getting results is because they are not taking action, because there is this fear and this lack of confidence. You have to realize that when people have joined, you won 2 points out of 3. The 3 points of why people don't join: they don't believe in you, they don't believe in your offer, or they don't believe in themselves. If they joined, they believe in you, they believe in your offer. Are you doing anything to help them believe in themselves? And some people will say, I am not a babysitter. I've heard it. Except that that doesn't work anymore. People will be out because now people want result. They want the help right away. They expect some type of AI bot. AI is everywhere. So how do we use it ethically, intelligently, not to replace support? We are not replacing anything, right? You still have the calls, you still have all these things, but it's this extra tool that builds the muscle of doing. And that's where you get clarity, that's where you get confidence, and that's where you we get to results. Ah, that's what I'm trying to, to say to people is like, there are a lot of things I hate about AI. I mean, I'm on LinkedIn a lot. I think we are connected on— yes, we are. All the posts, all the comments, like, I hate that part of AI, but that part here. I mean, the, the results we're getting for clients, 6— I, I shared this one, I think 60,000 conversations. In less than a year for 500-something people. Those are like 60,000 conversations with a tool that would have never happened. Andrew and Pete from Atomic, they are at like thousands and thousands of conversations from the Mavericks program. And actually, when we built it, they relaunched Maverick with Ask Tom as one of the main features. Like, you always have support. And people that were thinking, oh, if I add AI, people are going to think I'm lazy, the quality is not good. They're trying to step away and just, you know, like automate. Absolutely not. It's on top of, we still get all the calls in Mavericks because I'm also a client. So it's not about that. They just figured out that they need people to take action. You start with one thing and then you're like, okay, now So we have this whole service now where we analyze memberships because you were asking where people not necessarily know, right? So we have, and of course we use AI to really go through certain programs and figure out, oh, this is something they ask to do. What are the potential tension? And when you match that with what your members are actually telling you, then you've got real problems that people might have that they will never tell you unless you ask. And You can create tools around that. Another thing that I shared, I don't know if it's in this newsletter or another post, is that your people that are successful, you always ask them, why did it work? You know, why did you like? Because you wanna put that on your sales page, right? Start asking them, where did you get tripped? Because if you got tripped, other got, you got to the other side, but how many people are still stuck there? That's a great point. For creating a tool. It's a video I did maybe last week, maybe this— I don't know, I do videos every day at, at this time, so because I have a lot to say. It's like, find information where it is. If you ask somebody that went to the other side, you know, like, where are the places in the program where you could have used a bit more help, or it took you longer than, than you thought? Like, because like you said, I don't know how you said it, but like Everything is an experiment. We're called the Membership Lab for one thing, because everything is an experiment. And one day I have a book that is going to come out and it's going to be called The Membership Experiment. I haven't written it yet, but it's been in my head for years, right? So that's why it's like taking action and then just figuring out. It just— I know it's— people say that all the time, you know, like you either learn from the mistake or you get the benefit, but that's what it is. That's what it is, right? That's what gives you, it gives you data. Don't judge the data, then do, do something with the data that it gets you.
Speaker B: Yeah, 100%. And I think there's so many good tools now and, you know, some of these tools like PostHog or Mixpanel or whatever, they're, they're very technical tools, but the beautiful thing about AI is now you can have human conversa— you can install a tool that looks at everything a member does. I'm a big fan of PostHog. There's a lot of other ones. And then you can wait a week or two weeks and then you, you could go into Cloud Code and you could say, hey, like tell me something that is happening with the membership that maybe is reflecting a bad user experience. And it'd be like, oh, well I found like these three things and here's this one really big thing. And then you go and you look at it and you're like, holy shit, that This is like huge. This is— how did I not see this? And you have a data-driven conclusion and then you can go and fix this thing and make everyone's life better. And of course AI jumps to some weird conclusions and you, you have to make sure it's not hallucinating things and so forth. But that would have required really a lot of domain expertise with these tools, or you would have had to learn this tool by yourself and then learn to interpret all this data and those barriers are, are, are broken. You can, you can just talk like a human to AI and it'll, it'll, it'll make suggestions.
Speaker A: Yeah, absolutely. So, so what we do, and, and we really got started like 5, 6 years ago, back when AI was not, we didn't have all the tools that we have right now. So the AI tools we create, they're actually proprietary. This is a tool that we created. And then our clients own it. That means they can create more tools, right? All they pay is APIs, basically, right? So basically the idea is, because there is this danger, right, with AI, right? You put an AI tool everywhere, you have an assistant for everything, and then it becomes, it's like gamification. It becomes like way too much. And it's basically finding that balance. As you said, you know, you were talking about the data. I'm not familiar with your tool just because we, recreate our own stuff. But, uh, it's the very important piece is reporting. You know, when you, when you have these tools, you have an opportunity to collect data. So of course we know the questions that are the most asked, and that also gives you idea for more tools you can create, right? Because maybe there is a tool that needs to be broken in two, or maybe there are tools that need to be combined into one, right? So you also, like, when you have, I mean, one client, they have like 25, I think now they have 25 AI tools. You can see the percentage, the usage, which tool is being used, which one is not being used, and things like that. So when you— this, I don't know how you do it with, uh, PastHog, is that what it is? Yeah. If you can choose a level, but like, because we built it, we can basically build the reporting that the clients want to see. But we also do like have recommendations because people don't even necessarily think, right? Say, okay, so this would be nice. But I think that the AI for the members is so important, but the data that we can get as members, you know, as program owners on how it is used is so valuable because it can help you create an even better experience, you know, modify AI tools, create new ones. Maybe some that are not used, you know, take them out or things like that. That it's really about how can you integrate that data? You know, how can you capture the data that, that matters?
Speaker B: Absolutely. And I'll wrap up with a final question, which is, let's say one, one thing that comes to your mind, Nathalie, a founder or membership operator, let's call it, finishes this episode, this great interview with you and can change one thing this week. What's one actionable thing that somebody can do this week that is a big lever? Or try?
Speaker A: Yeah, I mean, depending what they are doing, but when you ask that, what comes to mind is start tracking or paying more attention to what members do and don't do. And I know what people are going to say because I hear it, but how? Because depending on what you're using, you have a platform and the platform tells you nothing. So that can be tricky. But like, I think the key before you do anything in your membership, because I don't know where you are, you know, you have a churn rate that is too high, right? Or people join, but they never even complete the onboarding, or maybe people are like, what is onboarding? Right? So I don't know where people are, but the first The first thing that I look at, like audit what your members are doing inside.
Speaker B: Yeah.
Speaker A: Right?
Speaker B: Maybe talk to them.
Speaker A: Talk to them.
Speaker B: Yeah.
Speaker A: You know, there are, there are people, so I think Pat Flynn does that. I don't know if he still does it, but if you want, you know, once in a while, it will pick someone from his program, call them.
Speaker B: Mm-hmm.
Speaker A: Randomly you get—
Speaker B: I bet that feels good.
Speaker A: From Patrick. Oh yeah, I bet it feels good. And just to get a pulse, you know, I don't know how many he does. So you can do things like that. You can reach out to members individually, the one that you see active, just to figure out like, are they just active busy or active getting results? And maybe the ones that you see, maybe they're logging, but they don't participate. Like you try to get like a poll of people. And I think that's before you do, you try anything, it's like What are you trying to improve?
Speaker B: Right.
Speaker A: So look at what your members are doing or not doing.
Speaker B: Natalie, thank you. That was a really wonderfully insightful take on taking great care of your members, using tool AI and various tools to understand what people are doing and then making data-driven decisions to improve their experience, taking ownership of your business and realizing that there's a lot more in your control than you probably would like to admit, because it does put a burden of performance on you. For everyone listening, you can learn more about Natalie at the Membership Lab, and the link is in the description of this episode. I'm Vic. This is MemberFix Radio. Subscribe to catch the next one.
Speaker A: Thank you so much for having me, Vic.